
Theory and Practice Case Files
Series 1: Theory of Change and Mind
Theory of Change and Mind Tuesday 29th September 2026 Case notes 01 - When our theory meets people. Imagine a service designed around a simple assumption: If we make support available, people will use it. It sounds reasonable. But what if the person we designed it for: • doesn't trust the organisation • has had a poor experience before • finds the process overwhelming • is worried about what asking for help might mean • doesn't recognise themselves in the language we use • is simply too cognitively overloaded to take the next step? The activity hasn't necessarily ‘failed’. Our theory about what would enable the behaviour may have been incomplete. This is where the intersection of Theory of Change X Theory of Mind can be so interesting together. The Theory of Change asks: What do we think will cause change? The mind asks: What might the person actually be thinking, feeling, and experiencing? And practice gives us another great question - What did reality teach us that our original theory missed? That really give us an opportunity for a practice-to-theory learning loop.

The Theory and Practice Casefiles - Theory of Change and Mind, Case File #02 The mental model hiding in the room. A service has a problem with missed appointments. The theory seems straightforward: People miss appointments because they forget, disengage or aren't motivated enough. So, the response is reminders. Better communications. Perhaps an incentive. But then co-design happens. People describe juggling work, caring responsibilities, unpredictable transport, previous experiences of judgement, anxiety about attending, and several services competing for their attention. The problem starts to look rather different. The intervention wasn't necessarily wrong. The mental model behind it may have been incomplete. This is one of the reasons the intersection of Theory of Change and Mind can be so helpful. A Theory of Change makes our causal assumptions more visible. A Theory of Mind encourages us to become curious about the assumptions we make about what people think, feel, know, and believe. And practice gives us the opportunity to challenge both. This is where systemic service design can become particularly powerful: Don't just design around the behaviour you observe. Get curious about the thinking, context and system that might be producing it. The Case File Question that I’ve been exploring this week: What mental model about people or behaviour is currently shaping your Theory of Change, and what evidence might challenge it?

What if people aren’t the problem, but our explanation is incomplete? What if changing our thinking could change the outcomes we create? The Theory and Practice Casefiles of a Pracademic Theory of Change and Mind | Case File #03: When assumptions pretend to be facts. Imagine a service offering support, but fewer people take it up than expected. We might assume people aren’t ready to change. But what else could we discover? Perhaps the timing doesn’t fit. The offer needs to feel safer, more relevant, or easier to access. Previous experiences shape trust. People are balancing competing priorities and responsibilities. These aren’t deficits in people. They’re opportunities to understand how services can work better with the realities of people’s lives. Our Theory of Change helps us explore how we believe change happens. Theory of Mind encourages us to consider the beliefs, feelings, intentions, and perspectives that shape how people experience that change. Together, they invite us to make assumptions visible, listen to lived experience, co-design possibilities and test our explanations against evidence. And crucially, to let practice change our theory, not just ask people to fit our theory. Our assumptions can be useful starting points. Our curiosity creates the opportunity to do better. Case File Question: Which assumption in your Theory of Change could you revisit, and what might people’s experiences help you discover?

A service can hit its targets and still miss what matters. Because measuring change is different from understanding it. And the outcomes we count don’t always tell us the difference we make in people’s lives. The Theory and Practice Casefiles of a Pracademic Theory of Change and Mind | Case File #04 When success looks good on paper Imagine a service celebrates an increase in completed appointments. The target is met. The numbers look promising. The intervention appears to be working. But do we know whether people felt listened to? Understood their options? Felt safe enough to ask questions? Left better equipped to take their next step? * Our Theory of Change helps us define the outcomes we expect and how we believe our actions will achieve them. * Theory of Mind reminds us that the same service encounter can mean very different things to different people. And co-design helps us explore those experiences rather than assume we already understand them. This isn’t about dismissing performance measures (let's face it they are way too important for a multitude of reasons). It’s about enriching them with lived expertise and experience, qualitative insight, and evidence of what matters to people. When we combine outcomes with experience, we can make better decisions about what to sustain, adapt or change. A reminder to measure what matters, and to stay curious about what your measures might be missing. Case File Question: What does success look like from the perspective of the people experiencing your service, and how would you know?

The Theory and Practice Case File 5 - Theory of Change and Mind (27th October 2026). This week’s Case File Question has been: What could people’s experiences teach us about the change a service is trying to create? We can design a service with the best intentions, and still misunderstand what makes change possible. Our Theory of Change explains how we expect our interventions to create the outcomes we want. But what about the people experiencing them? Theory of Mind invites us to explore how people interpret what we offer: what they believe, feel, value, expect and take away. Bringing the two together means testing our account of how change happens against how people actually experience the intervention. Imagine a support service with low uptake: Rather than assuming people aren’t ready, motivated, or engaged, we could ask: * What assumptions have we made about what people need? * How do people experience the service, and what matters to them? * What might their experiences reveal about the way we’ve designed support? * What could we test, adapt, or improve together? People bring strengths, knowledge and experience that can help us understand why change happens, and how to create better conditions for it. The aim isn’t to guess what people think. It’s to listen, learn, co-design and let evidence challenge our assumptions. Because our theories are useful starting points, not unquestionable truths.

The service is available. But can people actually access it? Making support available doesn't automatically make it accessible. And designing a simpler service doesn't mean we've made it easier for everyone to use. Theory of Change and Mind - Case File #06 (3rd November 2026) Our Theory of Change might suggest that making a service quicker, simpler, and available digitally will help more people access the support they need. But what assumptions sit behind that thinking? Do people have the technology, confidence, time, privacy, and trust to use it? Does it fit around their lives, relationships, and other responsibilities? Theory of Mind then invites us to explore how people interpret and experience the service. Systemic thinking helps us understand the wider conditions shaping their ability to access it. Together, these lenses encourage us to move beyond asking: “Why aren't people using our service?” And instead ask: “What would need to be true for people to access and benefit from the support they need?” This is where listening, co-design and real-world learning matter. We can recognise people's strengths; understand the barriers created by the system and adapt the conditions around them. This is a great reminder to not just design a service people can access in theory. It’s also about designing the conditions that help people access it in practice. This week’s Case File Question: What conditions around your service might be making access easier for some people, and harder for others?

An improvement in one part of a service can create opportunities elsewhere. But are we looking for the ripples? We often design interventions around the change we want to create. Yet the effects can travel much further than we anticipate. The Theory and Practice Case Files (Theory of Change and Mind - Case File #07) Imagine an organisation redesigning its customer or service-user support journey. A single digital access point, automated triage and streamlined referrals promise: Simpler access | quicker responses | better support | improved outcomes. But what happens across the rest of the service? Some people gain independence. Others need more support. Enquiries move between teams and demand shifts across channels. This is where our two theories can become very powerful. Theory of Change helps us understand the causal pathways and assumptions behind the change we intend. Theory of Mind invites us to explore how different people interpret and experience that change. Together, they encourage us to look beyond individual interactions, listen to different perspectives, identify feedback loops, and learn from the wider effects. Systemic service design, co-design, and improvement science help us turn those insights into opportunities to adapt and improve. Every intervention creates ripples. The opportunity is to understand where they travel and what we can learn from them. Case File Question: Where are the ripples of change travelling across your service or organisation — and whose experiences could help you strengthen them?
